Did Neandertals Wear Ornaments?

A small but tantalizing find provides further evidence for Neandertal culture.  Working in the foothills of the Alps just north of Venice, Italy, researchers have discovered and analyzed a small marine shell that originally came from about 60 miles away.  It was thinly coated with a dark red substance that turns out to be pure hematite and was most likely used as a pigment.  One possibility is that the shell was used as an ornament.

The paper, freely available online in the journal PLoS One, dates the shell’s pigmentation to a period just before 45,000 years ago, right before the arrival of so-called “modern” humans in Europe. 

Photo Caption: A shell possibly "painted" by Neandertals about 45,000 years ago.  Photo available from PLoS One.

According to the paper, “deliberate transport and coloring of an exotic object, and perhaps its use as pendant, was a component of Neandertal symbolic culture, well before the earliest appearance of the anatomically modern humans in Europe.”

Quoting more of the paper, “this discovery adds to the ever-increasing evidence that Neandertals had symbolic items as part of their culture.”

Debates about Neandertal culture have intensified recently, in part because of genetic evidence of interbreeding between Neandertals and the modern humans coming into Asia and Europe.  While these modern humans began their migration out of Africa about 80,000 years ago and probably interbred around 55,000 years ago, they did not reach Europe until more like 40,000 years ago.  If all these dates hold up in future research, this shell does provide a small but intriguing hint about the culture of Neandertals at just about the time of their encounter with “modern” humans. 

So who exactly is modern?  The differences between ourselves (the humans we like to call “modern”) and the Neandertals are not as great than we once imagined.  The paper ends with these words: “Future discoveries will only add to our appreciation of Neandertals shared capacities with us.”

The paper, entitled "An Ochered Fossil Marine Shell From the Mousterian of FumaneCave, Italy," appears in the current issue of PLoS One and is freely available online.