Still wondering..."What Defines Us?"

Last February the editors of Science marked the 10th anniversary of the publication of the complete human genome. They invited a dozen or so people to contribute short reflections on the meaning of this milestone.

I was given 250 words for my article, entitled “What Defines Us?” In that small space I tried to suggest two things. First I noted a simple irony: As we gain more scientific information about our genome and our evolution, the philosophical and religious concepts of humanity become blurred or defocused. Second, I suggested that this defocusing need not be a cause for discomfort. Precisely because we are humans—whatever exactly that means anymore—we switch almost immediately from discomfort to wonder and excitement. The quick switch is what makes us human. I ended by asking: “Who are we, and where will we go next?”

It is as if we are making ourselves up as we go along. Recent discoveries in human evolution intimate just such a view. Anatomically modern humans are now believed to have interbred with Neandertals and with the more recently discovered Denisovans. Many of us carry the DNA of these extinct forms of humanity in our own genome. In that sense they are not distinct at all but live on in every cell of our bodies. More recently, it has been suggested that similar interbreeding occurred in sub-Saharan Africa.

Interestingly, it has also been suggested that interbreeding enhanced us. In August, a research article in Science suggested that our immune systems are more resilient than they might have been. Why? Because our ancestors interbred with Neandertals and Denisovans.

The evolutionary tree of humanity is beginning to look less like a tree and more like a tangled vine. And now we are led to wonder whether it is the tangle that enhances us. What makes us less clearly Homo sapiens seems, paradoxically, to make us more extraordinary as a species. Well…we’re running far ahead of the science here, but (as I suggested in Science), wondering is what makes us human. It’s not just the DNA; it’s what we dare to do with it.

I have been thinking about this recently because I will be speaking on November 10 on this very topic at the University of South Florida Saint Petersburg. They have planned an exciting lecture series, Festival of the Genome: Celebrating the 10th Anniversary of the Sequencing of the Human Genome, showcasing various perspectives on human genome research.