Spreading Farming, Spreading Genes

Agriculture probably originated in the Middle East about 11,000 years ago. Over the next six thousand years, it spread to other parts of the globe, including northern Europe, gradually replacing hunting and gathering as the primary means of human survival.

How did it spread? Were hunter-gatherers converted to the efficiencies of agriculture? Or did farmers from the south spread north, bringing their agriculture with them?

A new study suggests that farming spread because farmers moved. The movement was slow, taking five to six thousand years to reach Scandinavia. Early in the process, farmers of southern ancestry lived side by side with their more northerly human cousins, who still lived by hunting and gathering. Eventually, after a thousand years or so, farmers interbred with hunter-gatherers and farming became the dominant way of life.

The new study, which appears in the April 27 issue of Science, is based on an analysis of four skeletons, all found in Sweden and dating from about 5,000 years ago. Three were hunter-gatherers and one was a farmer. All of them lived their entire lives close to where they were buried, the hunter-gatherers in a flat grave and the farmer a stone megalith like the one pictured below.

Caption: Several hundred megalith tombs are known from the Falbygden area, including Gökhem and Valle parishes in Östergötland,Sweden.Credit: Göran Burenhult

"We know that the hunter-gatherer remains were buried in flat-bed grave sites, in stark contrast to the megalithic sites that the farmers built," said Mattias Jakobsson, a senior author from Uppsala University. "The farmer we analyzed was buried under such a megalith, and that's just one difference that helps distinguish the two cultures," Jakobsson said in a press release issued by the journal.

What is most significant in this study comes from an analysis of the human DNA extracted from the four skeletons. By studying their DNA, researchers found that the farmer belonged to a community with ancestral roots in the eastern Mediterranean, most closely resembling today's Greeks and Cypriots. The hunter-gatherers, on the other hand, were more like today’s northern Europeans, most closely resembling today's Finns. "What is interesting and surprising is that Stone Age farmers and hunter-gatherers from the same time had entirely different genetic backgrounds and lived side by side for more than a thousand years, to finally interbreed," Jakobsson said.

Caption: The skeleton belongs to a young female in her 20s, and can be dated to around 4,700 years ago. Credit: Göran Burenhult

"The results suggest that agriculture spread across Europe in concert with a migration of people," added Pontus Skoglund, also of Uppsala University. "If farming had spread solely as a cultural process, we would not expect to see a farmer in the north with such genetic affinity to southern populations."

The article, entitled "Origins and Genetic Legacy of Neolithic Farmers and Hunter-Gatherers in Europe," appears in the April 27 issue of Science, published by the American Association for the Advancement of Science.

Synthetic Biology: Is There Life beyond DNA?

Life as we know it is based on DNA and RNA. Could it have been otherwise? Might other worlds have life based on a different “genetic” system? We may never know for sure.

But we do know that synthetic biology is moving briskly toward the goal of engineered life beyond DNA and RNA.

Recall that in “DNA” and “RNA,” the “NA” part stands for “nucleic acids.” It’s the four nucleic acids that carry the genetic information in a chemical code. The “D” and the “R,” however, stand for sugars that hold the nucleic acids in place, allowing them to form pairs and to copy themselves. Can other sugars work as well?

Recent work in synthetic biology has led beyond DNA and RNA to xeno-nucleic acids or “XNAs.” Now, using six different forms of XNAs, an international team of researchers led by Vitor Pinheiro reports success in getting XNAs to store and propagate information. One of their XNAs actually “evolved” by responding to imposed selective constraints. Their work is published in the April 20, 2012 issue of the journal Science.

Caption: Courtesy--National Human Genome Research Institute

In a commentary on the research, Gerald F. Joyce writes in Science that this work has implications for the “understanding of life itself.” In addition, it opens new insight into the possible origins of life on our planet or else where in the cosmos.

At the same time, far more work lies ahead before synthetic biologists create XNA-based life. Pinheiro’s team was able to get their synthetic XNA “genes” to interact with DNA, but “they have not yet realized a synthetic genetic system.” One big challenge is in getting XNA sequences to copy themselves the way DNA does. Some XNAs can copy themselves to DNA and back again to XNA, but XNA-to-XNA copying is not reliable.

According to Joyce, however, “future studies are likely to yield improvements of the the various XNA-to-XNA copying reaction.” If that happens, synthetic biology will take yet another step toward “synthetic genetics.”

All this prompts a warning from Joyce: “Synthetic biologists are beginning to frolic on the worlds of alternative genetics but must not tread into areas that have the potential to harm our biology.” As ever, greater knowledge brings greater risks. More than ever, public awareness and careful thought are needed.

The research article, "Synthetic Genetic Polymers Capable of Heredity and Evolution" and the commentary, "Toward an Alternative Biology," are both published in the April 20, 2012 issue of Science, the journal of the American Association for the Advancement of Science.

A Million Years of Fire

One of our newest technologies has just shed new light on one of our oldest.

When did our human ancestors learn to control and use fire? Armed with the latest high tech tools, an international team of researchers has pushed the date back to 1 million years. That’s 300,000 years earlier than previous unambiguous dates.

The massive Wonderwerk Cave is in northern South Africa on the edge of the Kalahari. Previous excavations have shown extensive human occupation. Using the new techniques of micromorphological analysis and Fourier transform infrared microspectroscopy (mFTIR), researchers analyzed cave sediments at a far more detailed level than possible before.

Caption: This is a panoramic view of the entrance to Wonderwerk Cave, South Africa. Credit: H. Ruther. Usage Restrictions: None

In the cave sediments researchers found bits of ash from plants along with fragments of burned bone. Did the wind blow burning debris into the cave? The evidence—collected about 100 feet from the current opening of the cave—supports the conclusion that the fire burned in the cave. Also part of the proof: the surrounding surfaces are discolored.

”The analysis pushes the timing for the human use of fire back by 300,000 years, suggesting that human ancestors as early as Homo erectus may have begun using fire as part of their way of life," anthropologist Michael Chazan said in a press release from the University of Toronto.

According to the paper, "Through the application of micromorphological analysis and Fourier transform infrared microspectroscopy (mFTIR) of intact sediments and examination of associated archaeological finds— fauna, lithics, and macrobotanical remains—we provide unambiguous evidence in the form of burned bone and ashed plant remains that burning events took place in Wonderwerk Cave during the early Acheulean occupation, approximately 1.0 Ma. To date, to the best of our knowledge, this is the earliest secure evidence for burning in an archaeological context."

Caption: Interior of Wonderwerk Cave. Images courtesy of M. Chazan.

"The control of fire would have been a major turning point in human evolution," says Chazan. "The impact of cooking food is well documented, but the impact of control over fire would have touched all elements of human society. Socializing around a camp fire might actually be an essential aspect of what makes us human."

How important are fire and cooking for human evolution. A recent book, Catching Fire: How Cooking Made Us Human by Richard Wrangham, argues that cooking is essential to our humanity. Now in the paper published on April 2, the team concludes that its study “is the most compelling evidence to date offering some support for the cooking hypothesis of Wrangham.”

Their work is published as “Microstratigraphic evidence of in situ fire in the Acheulean strata of Wonderwerk Cave, Northern Cape Province, South Africa,” in the April 2, 2012 issue of the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.