Deep Brain Cognitive Enhancement: The Latest News

The search for new methods of cognitive enhancement has just reached new depths.  Researchers in Austria and the UK report exciting new evidence that a form of noninvasive deep brain stimulation enhances the brain’s ability to do arithmetic. 

"With just five days of cognitive training and noninvasive, painless brain stimulation, we were able to bring about long-lasting improvements in cognitive and brain functions," says Roi Cohen Kadosh of the University of Oxford and lead author of the report that appears in the May 16, 2013 issue of Current Biology.  His comments were provided by the journal.

Photo Credit.  Photo by Ad Meskens of an original oil painting by Laurent de La Hyre (French, 1606-1656).  The title of the painting is Allegory of Arithmetic (Allegorie van de rekenkunde) and it dates to about 1650.  The original painting is in the Walters Art Museum, Baltimore, Maryland.  It was photographed on 18 July 2007 by Ad Meskens, who has made it freely available with proper credit.

In this study, the team used a form of noninvasive deep brain stimulation known as “transcranial random noise stimulation” or TRNS.  The TRNS input was combined with more traditional math training and drills.  Twenty-five young adults, males and females, were divided into two groups, one receiving math training with the TRNS and the other receiving math training combined with a “sham” version of TRNS, a kind of placebo. 

Not only did those who received TRNS do well immediately, but the benefits lasted for at least six months.  In addition, brain monitors detected different brain activity for those receiving TRNS.  This suggests that TRNS modifies brain function.

According to Cohen Kadosh, "If we can enhance mathematics, therefore, there is a good chance that we will be able to enhance simpler cognitive functions."

In the paper’s conclusion, the authors state that TRNS “can enhance learning with respect to high-level cognitive functions, namely algorithmic manipulation and factual recall in mental arithmetic. When this learning is based on deep-level cognitive processing, as is the case for calculation arithmetic, such enhancements are extremely long-lived both behaviorally and physiologically.

Then they sum up with these words:

Both the behavioral and physiological changes displayed extreme longevity, spanning a period of 6 months, but only when learning involved deep-level cognitive processing. By its demonstration of such longevity and, for the calculation task, generalization to new, unlearned material, the present study highlights TRNS as a promising tool for enhancing high-level cognition and facilitating learning. These findings have significant scientific and translational implications for cognitive enhancement in both healthy individuals and patients suffering from disorders characterized by arithmetic deficits.

The paper, Snowball et al.: "Long-Term Enhancement of Brain Function and Cognition Using Cognitive Training and Brain Stimulation," appears in the May 16, 2013 issue of Current Biology. 

Enhancement at Work: A New Report

A new report on human enhancement and its growing impact on the workplace has just been released by top-level British science and policy groups. The Royal Society, the Academy of Medical Science, the British Academy, and the Royal Academy of Engineering collaborated on a research project throughout 2012, resulting in the November 2012 report.

Image from the cover of Human Enhancement and the Future of Work.

Among the conclusions: "Advances in a range of areas in science and engineering such as neuroscience, regenerative medicine and bionics are already enhancing, or could in the next decade enhance, the physical and cognitive capacity of individuals in the workplace." The report is entitled Human Enhancement and the Future of Work.

Even the advocates of human enhancement find something uniquely troubling about the prospect of enhancement technologies in the workplace. Will employers coerce their workers? Will use of enhancement technology be a non-negotiable prerequisite for success in an increasingly competitive work environment? Will employees have full access to information about potential side-effects?

The report notes the following: "Cognitive-enhancing drugs present the greatest immediate challenge...They are already available without prescription through internet purchasing, are relatively cheap and are increasinly being used by healthy individuals."

In response to these challenges, the report does not recommend sanctions or bans, but it does press the case urgently for widening the dialogue and reforming policies and regulations.

Resveratrol and Enhancement? Not So Fast

Does resveratrol help healthy people become even healthier? Does it improve metabolic health and possibly even help us live longer?

A new study casts doubts on these hopes. In the October 25 issue of Cell Metabolism, researchers at Washington University School of Medicine publish the results of their study involving 29 healthy middle-aged women. They asked whether resveratrol boosts metabolic health. When they ran the tests and collected the evidence, the answer was simple: No.

The study divided the women into two groups. Fifteen were given 75 milligrams of resveratrol each day, the same as they would get in 8 liters (more than 10 bottles) of red wine. The other fourteen received a sugar-pill placebo.

Researchers measured the women's sensitivity to insulin and the rate of the glucose uptake. The result, according to Samuel Klein, senior investigator, is that "we were unable to detect any effect of resveratrol. In addition, we took small samples of muscle and fat tissue from these women to look for possible effects of resveratrol in the body's cells, and again, we could not find any changes in the signaling pathways involved in metabolism," Klein said in a press release issued by Washington University School of Medicine.

Photo Credit: Robert Boston. No usage restrictions.

This study is small, but what makes it interesting is that it involves healthy human beings. In nonhuman trials, resveratrol seems to enhance the health of healthy animals. And in human trials involving people with metabolic problems, resveratrol seems beneficial.

According to Klein, "Few studies have evaluated the effects of resveratrol in people," Klein explains. "Those studies were conducted in people with diabetes, older adults with impaired glucose tolerance or obese people who had more metabolic problems than the women we studied. So it is possible that resveratrol could have beneficial effects in people who are more metabolically abnormal than the subjects who participated in the study."

That point goes right to the heart of the human enhancement debate. Often, "enhancement" is distinguished from therapy. While therapy improves the health of the sick, enhancement improves the health of the healthy. This study seems to suggest that resveratrol may be therapeutic, but it is not an enhancement.

Right now, however, the picture is not completely clear. Those who drink red wine in moderation are less likely than others to develop heart disease and diabetes? Is it the resveratrol, the wine, or the interactions between them?

According to Klein, "We were unable to detect a metabolic benefit of resveratrol supplementation in our study population, but this does not preclude the possibility that resveratrol could have a synergistic effect when combined with other compounds in red wine."

The article, entitled "Resveratrol Supplementation Does Not Improve Metabolic Function in Nonobese Women with Normal Glucose Tolerance," appears in the October 25 issue of Cell Metabolism.